The faces
of these inhabitants are often obscured, much like the interview subjects have
their visages covered. However, viewers clearly witness these individuals doing
yoga, folding laundry, cleaning tables. So many mundane tasks. Often their
televisions blare propaganda justifying and normalizing the slaughter of
Palestinians.
These
cutaways from the assorted interviews depict a level of comfort Palestinian
civilians can’t obtain. Sure, rockets can race overhead in Tel Aviv. Generally,
though, this population goes about its business like any other major city. NAZA
features wide shots of people eating and laughing at nice restaurants. Folks
dance to trap music. People are catching a jog before dawn breaks. The
dissonance between these banal images of normalcy and a genocide happening in
Gaza just under 70 kilometers away is chilling.
Abraham
and Szor don’t need intrusive music or narration to hammer home this eerie
reality. Juxtaposing unspeakably horrifying anecdotes with these subdued images
is enough. This is what normalized colonization looks like.
Those
anecdotes, though, are NAZA’s primary focus. These accounts come from
various Israeli’s recounting their work in killing Palestinians. The country’s
government further ramped up this task after October 7, 2023. In matter-of-fact
tones, they recall matters like using phones to track down the location of
Palestinian citizens and nonchalant attitudes towards the death of children. These
are the architects of mass slaughter. These are their stories. NAZA
bears witness to how unthinkable war crimes become another nine-to-five job.
Or, as one
interview subject puts it, "I know now how people can bomb a house and
then return home to their clinical engineering degrees."
Abraham
and Szor’s cameras and interviews reveal wildly varying forms of wiping out
Palestinians. One person recalls various techniques used to set fire to homes.
Another elaborates on how snipers were told to promptly kill starving Palestinians
who scrambled towards aid. Then there’s the folks NAZA focuses on
towards the end of its runtime. These were the souls responsible for curbing
Palestinians from going to the International Criminal Court or other bodies that
could hold Israeli forces accountable for their crimes.
One individual
that they’d dig up dirt on whoever was planning to speak up (an extramarital
affair, perhaps, or concealed homosexuality) and use that to ensure they’d
never come forward. These particular people aren’t using drones or guns per se,
but they’re still robbing Palestinians of their humanity and autonomy. That’s
the binding force behind NAZA’s interview subjects. Dehumanizing the “other”
and justifying unthinkable atrocities. Even when children are murdered, there’s
always a rationale.
To say NAZA
is a harrowing watch is an understatement. Abraham and Szor’s intentionally
subdued visual aesthetic proves crucial in this regard. This includes the
soundtrack, which largely consists of genocide-enabler testimonies accompanied
by distant sounds of airplanes landing, car horns, or faint conversations. This
auditory landscape keeps the focus squarely on horrific anecdotes often erased
and suppressed (anti-Israel
graffiti is a “hate crime” in certain parts of Texas). However, like those
shots of apartment-dwelling Tel Aviv denizens, those faraway noises make it
clear these interview subjects aren’t anomalous individuals or “a few bad
apples.”
They inhabit
a larger world, one in which the normalization of colonialism and genocide of
Indigenous souls goes far beyond Israel’s borders. I’m typing this on unceded
land from tribes like the Caddo, Wichita, Tawakoni, and Kiikaapoi people. Indigenous
peoples in Brazil are constantly under threat from violence and exploitation.
Justifying crimes against humanity and the elimination of Indigenous lives is
everywhere. Abraham and Szor’s auditory and visual NAZA impulses
reinforce this grander scope without distracting from the gut-wrenching
testimonies at hand.
Such
statements include stories about how drone strike operators took to processing
these missions “like a video game.” Others recall how their co-workers cheered
on these slayings. One interview subject, while expressing remorse for the
past, openly admits feeling a unique and thrilling adrenaline surge carrying
out killings. It’s staggering that the NAZA crew got these words on
camera (even with the appearances and voices of the various military personnel
changed). Then again, briefly seen news footage shows various Israeli
politicians boasting about eliminating Palestinians from the face of the Earth.
Perhaps it shouldn’t be surprising what genocide architects and enablers say
once they’re shrouded in shadows.
NAZA only shifts away from its default
visual scheme once for its final scene. This segment consists of footage
captured on a phone by a Palestinian citizen. An IDF airstrike has just decimated
civilian Gaza territory. Thus, this phone chronicles neighbors navigating the
wreckage of their homes for their loved ones. One father calls to his children,
now buried underneath rubble. As the realization of what’s happened to them
sets in, the man moans, sobs, and recalls how he told his son to watch out for
his sister. His agonizing cries are one of many wails and heart-shattering
noises filling the screen.
Up to this
point, NAZA has emphasized stories of people who make war crimes
possible. Now audiences see the human cost of treating people “like a video
game” from the point-of-view of a Palestinian citizen living through this
genocide.
Once the
lights went up at my NAZA screening, as the credits silently rolled on,
an unusual thing happened. Nobody got up. We all sat silently, processing
everything we’d just witnessed. So impactful was this filmmaking and overall
movie that suddenly bolting from the premises felt insulting. Gradually, we all
stood up and slowly ventured towards the exits. Outside the theater, it was
only 12:30 PM. The sun was shining down. Yet NAZA’s harrowing nighttime
interviews consumed my mind and, undoubtedly, everyone else in that auditorium
that day.

No comments:
Post a Comment