Bittersweet dark comedies. Those three words neatly sum up playwright and feature film writer/director Martin McDonagh's cinematic exploits. Melancholy ambiances linger over his motion pictures like a storm cloud hovering above a picnic or U.S. government forces preparing to attack a democratically elected leftist leader. Titles like The Banshees of Inisherin and In Bruges make that aesthetic apparent. McDonagh films feature bleak yuks (often derived from witty vulgar verbiage) within mournful, deeply vulnerable atmospheres.
Even his wacky Hollywood yukfest, Seven Psychopaths, ends with a mournful exchange in a phone booth where Colin Farrell’s protagonist quietly accepts that death will eventually come for him (“That's good,” his character remarks upon hearing when he’ll die, “I'm not doing anything Tuesday.”).
Now McDonagh’s aesthetic is back with his latest big screen venture, Wild Horse Nine. Here, he zeroes in on CIA officers and best friend Chris Carlisle (John Malkovich) and Lee Chesterfield (Sam Rockwell). After laying the groundwork for the 1973 Chilean coup d'etat, Carlisle and Chesterfield head to an Easter Island vacation. The former member of this pair has killed 68 people in his life, destabilized countless governments, and left a legacy of America-sanctioned bloodshed. He’s also now succumbing to his older age. His memory isn’t working. Cancer ravages his body. The Grim Reaper’s preparing to visit someone used to dishing out death.
McDonagh shrewdly heightens the tension and places audiences closer to Carlisle’s perspective by slowly unfurling key Wild Horse Nine details as the story progresses rather than unveiling everything upfront. That includes key promises between Carlisle and Chesterfield that this older spy has forgotten all about, how long this cancer-ridden character has to live, as well as their boss, MJ (Steve Buscemi), demanding Chesterfield kill his best friend. Easter Island is one of the world’s most beautiful places. Glorious sights abound in this domicile. Yet even here spies can’t escape conspiracies and potentially fatal secrets.
Midway through Wild Horse Nine, Carlisle and Chesterfield are sitting on a hill and conversing. As they chat, one shot of Carlisle suddenly got darker. I was temporarily worried my theater's projector system wasn’t working. However, the subsequent image of Chesterfield wielded not only the same lighting, but suddenly returned to the initial brightness. McDonagh and cinematographer Ben Davis kept in images where clouds briefly obscured the sun. They couldn’t control that reality-based wrinkle, yet they rolled with it during their practical location shooting.
That might sound like a weird, superfluous detail to obsess over. Maybe it is. But after watching The Social Reckoning’s artificial rendering of exterior rainy spaces, I absolutely cherished these remnants of reality. Tiny elements like that make Wild Horse Nine’s world extra believable. These aren’t characters discernibly existing only on blue-screen simulacra of the outdoors. They’re outside, breathing the air and beholden to when clouds briefly overtake the sun. Embracing such visual elements accentuates the believability of Wild Horse Nine’s characters.
Nobody can dispute that McDonagh is a master of insults. Whether it's "you're an inanimate object!" or declaring someone "fecking mental," his films are littered with characters creatively lambasting one another. Wild Horse Nine happily continues that trend. Chesterfield’s intensely uttering "you dumb Iowa cunt" is especially sublime. McDonagh’s writing isn’t just rife with jeers. It’s also heavy on immensely engaging conversations between Carlise and Chesterfield that intriguingly evolve tonally as Wild Horse Nine progresses. At first, they’re mostly just amusing as Carlisle rambles on about his supposed “wisdom.” Monologues regarding the correlation between gayness and democracy, as well as how having a heroin addict for a wife is superior to being married to an alcoholic, are particularly memorable in this regard.
However, as the story marches on, more dramatic impulses begin seeping into their conversations. Carlisle isn’t sure he can trust his longtime friend while Chesterfield finds himself pulled between dueling alliances. Inevitably, their rapport gets more strained. This still produces amusing material, like in one scene where Carlisle comes clean about how much he really wanted to see Venice, Italy rather than Easter Island. However, McDonagh wrings impactful power out of contorting an initially comedic dynamic into something outright tragic. Wild Horse Nine is often a two-hander between Rockwell and Malkovich. Whatever mode that two-hander inhabits, it proves engrossing.
The only real problem in the script is that the women characters needed more dimensions. Cinema legend Parker Posey (Party Girl forever!) is just around for two scenes playing Chesterfield’s wife back in the States. Chilean college student Monica (Mariana di Girolamo), meanwhile, has an understandable bittersweet function in the plot with her friendship with Carlisle ("She's life and I'm departing it," Carlisle bemoans). However, her interior world remains surface-level. At least her screentime, though, lets Girolamo demonstrate her serious mastery of an instantly shattering crying face. Tears welling up in her eyes resonate as achingly soul and believable rather than manipulative.
Besides that screenwriting foible, though, Wild Horse Nine is another divine film script from the In Bruges writer. While a dialogue-driven affair, McDonagh gladly maintains sharp visual instincts beyond maintaining takes where clouds obscured the sun. That includes littering the screen with bright colors. Hotel room phone cords are bright blue. Chesterfield never goes anywhere without a vibrant shirt on his body. Key automobiles are decked out in sumptuous colors like red. Folks like production designer Denis Schnegg and costume designer Eimer Ní Mhaoldomhnaigh prove essential in draping the on-screen world in enough vivid hues to evoke a postcard for an island getaway.
Committing to those colors (not to mention Easter Island’s natural beauty) ensures that Wild Horse Nine’s melancholy elements hit extra hard. It’s like how a storm makes it easier to appreciate sunlight. An evocatively staged shot depicting Chesterfield drinking alone at the hotel bar, empty space surrounding him, is one of several memorable images conveying this bittersweet tone. Inhabiting these visuals are a bevy of immensely memorable performances, including John Malkovich as Wild Horse Nine’s deeply vulnerable protagonist.
It's been a long while since Malkovich appeared in a top-shelf movie. After a few years of attempting to liven up titles like Fool's Paradise and Opus, Malkovich finally excels in a sublime motion picture once more. Especially memorable is any instant where he portrays Carlisle silently sitting, ruminating on his impending demise. Malkovich’s eyes suggest caked-in resignation with just a hint of fear. His character’s motormouth comedic digressions may suggest otherwise, but this actor's quietest details poignantly convey how much mortality weighs on Carlisle.
Sam Rockwell, reuniting with McDonagh for the third time, meanwhile, is also tonally dexterous in his performance. He’s an absolute riot bouncing off his elderly companion. Plus, Rockwell’s the master of hysterical facial expressions, a talent informing Wild Horse Nine’s greatest scenes. However, when it’s time for Rockwell to sell Chesterfield’s emotionally conflicted sequences, he absolutely crushes it. He and Malkovich uncover discernible and engrossing humanity within two monsters. On paper, that sounds like a paradox. Given that Wild Horse Nine is yet another bittersweet dark comedy triumph from Martin McDonagh, though, conceptually contradictory endeavors are the name of the game here.






.jpeg)




