Nathan
Fielder has spent years melting brains, inspiring GIFs, encountering wacky real-life
people, and showing off those really good grades he got from one of Canada’s
top business schools. Beyond inspiring unforgettable giggles, Fielder’s artistic
M.O. has impressed through (among other accomplishments) pervasive rug-pulls
revealing reality's immense malleability. A daycare location for a nighttime
meeting between taxi drivers on Nathan For You, for instance, can
suddenly be revealed as a set.
The
outstanding Nathan For You series finale Finding Frances explored
how much Fielder knew about and could trust elderly Bill Gates impersonator Bill
Heath. This guy kept making Fielder question how much he really knew about a
man who was constantly on his TV show.
Then there
was The Rehearsal, which had Fielder diving through and intersecting so
many layers of simulated realities. Throughout all these projects, jokes
persist, but so does the sense that what you’re watching can upend itself at
any moment. Who knows when Fielder will ratchet things up to the next level of
insanity (like bringing a live alligator into an electronics store) or suddenly
reveal that everything you’ve seen is a falsehood? Whether it’s a viral video
of a pig saving a goat or recreations of Sully Sullenberger listening to Evanescence,
Nathan Fielder’s comedy dares us to question what is real and what’s behind
those modulations to reality.
That makes
Fielder a perfect person to capture the world of Elizabeth Holmes, the former Theranos
mastermind and Silicon Valley figurehead who has been convicted of fraud. This
woman exists in her own labyrinthine approach to reality, one in which she
maintains her innocence. You Can See Everything (which is helmed by
Fielder and Primetime director Lance Oppenheimer) starts with Fielder capturing
Holmes, her husband Billy Evans, and their two kids in a lavish beachside San
Diego home. He arrives as this woman prepares for her imminent prison sentence
starting in a month.
With every
image captured in the Academy ratio (1.33:1) and the camera often resorting to
close-ups echoing similarly cramped frames in Oppenheim’s Primetime, You
Can See Everything starts with Fielder and his documentary subjects
confined close together. Despite this intimate proximity, concrete answers
elude him. Attempts to interview certain people (like Holmes’ father) only
inspire ire from Evans. Holmes, meanwhile, speaks in odd statements that both seemingly
only make sense to her and are weirdly devoid of malice. When she insists “I’ve
never told a lie,” she says it with such assurance…even though it’s clearly false.
Even
staring straight into her eyes and maintaining a conversation can’t quite part
the curtains and deliver a clear-cut truth. It’s utterly fascinating watching
Fielder scrounging for any kind of clarity from Holmes and Evans. He’s got to
get creative trying to create a bridge between himself and these idiosyncratic
souls, like using an Abbot & Costello routine to illustrate to
Holmes how her communication style may create understanding gaps between
herself and other people. Meanwhile, dry comedy ensues when Fielder tries
cracking jokes (“I used to do a comedy show about business scams...but you
actually did a business scam.”) around people who aren’t exactly joke-oriented.
Another
later illuminating You Can See Everything conversation involves people
talking about celebrity-based documentaries. When someone brings up a Meghan
Markle doc made for Netflix, another person responds, “that’s…not really a
documentary.” This comment speaks to a larger rot plaguing modern documentary
movies. Streamers have saturated the market with celebrity-focused
documentaries only existing to marvel at how big Eddie Murphy’s house is or provide
cozy PR management for historical monsters.
Interesting
visuals? Chronicling everyday people? Actually challenging viewers? These Hoop
Dreams, The Gleaners and I, and All the Beauty and the Bloodshed fixtures have no room in the new streaming-approved definition of documentary cinema. Features
previously chastising the powerful are now another tool normalizing the bourgeoisie.
Amazon’s Melania earlier this year was the blonde-haired, dead-eyed epitome
of this disgusting trend.
You Can
See Everything, like
fellow excellent 2020s docs Time or Crip Camp, reclaims the
documentary format back to actual filmmakers. Instead of just rehashing the
familiar, Fielder and Oppenheim use documentary cinema to keep audiences on
their toes. The camerawork isn’t what you might expect. Various twists and
turns navigated through the 170-minute runtime are similarly shocking. Even Ari
Balouzian's score (which apparently leans heavily on Bernard Hermann's compositions
from Vertigo) doesn’t quite sound like typical orchestral music
accompanying a movie about infamous Silicon Valley residents.
Then there’s
You Can See Everything’s willingness to challenge its central subjects. Previously,
Fielder had no problem pushing back on Boston-originating detectives or someone
dropping anti-Semitic remarks in a recreation of a Raising Cane’s. Naturally
then, he’s got no issue pushing the buttons of Elizabeth Holmes or Billy
Holmes. The celebrity documentary has teeth and subversiveness again. Nathan
Fielder rescued the format just in the nick of time.
As for
further specifics of what You Can See Everything has to offer…far be it
from me to spoil the mind-melting surprises waiting in store. Even Nathan
Fielder veterans like myself will be left agog over what he pulls off here. One
spoiler-free element I can praise here, though, is the way Fielder poses
himself on camera here. Audiences first see Fielder staring at Holmes from
behind a yellow-tinted door. Like so many shots of him looming over sets or
conversations in The Rehearsal, he’s framed almost like a horror movie
villain.
There’s something
persistently amusing about just cutting to a shot of Fielder with that blank
stare on his face just watching something from afar. Yet it’s also a neat
visual detail laced with many potential meanings. Are we seeing Fielder from
the perspective of the Holmes family, as an intrusive “monster”? Is this
supposed to reinforce Fielder as being an “other” in a space full of Silicon
Valley weirdos? This surface-level amusing image’s ambiguity once more forces
audiences to question what we’re looking at.
He’s a pilot. He’s saved so many American businesses. He even appeared briefly in Marcel the Shell with Shoes On. Now Nathan Fielder adds another achievement to his repertoire: theatrical film director. With this documentary, he and Oppenheim balloon typical Fielder creative impulses to 170 minutes without straining in the slightest. It isn’t just that You Can See Everything avoids feeling like a bloated Nathan For You episode. Instead, a larger canvas brings out new highs in artistic proficiency from this master comedian. Trust me, You Can See Everything’s extraordinary; it may be the best movie of 2026. Why would I deceive you about that?









.jpeg)
