When artists you love deliver something subpar, it's frustrating, even disorienting. No artist has a perfect track record, yet it can feel that way when experiencing certain great works. The Lost World: Jurassic Park vanishes from one's mind while absorbing Steven Spielberg's A.I. Artificial Intelligence or The Fabelmans. Futurama's most extraordinary episodes make it daft to imagine it could deliver the perfunctory installments littering its Comedy Central or Hulu runs. Listening to the nonstop bangers populating Taylor Swift's 1989, it's unthinkable that the same artist would succumb to the insipid lyricism infecting The Life of a Showgirl.
Director Richard Linklater, meanwhile, is not a filmmaker devoid of critical misfires. Many gave a thumbs down to his 2017 motion picture Last Flag Flying (I liked it, dammnit!), while his 2019 title Where'd You Go, Bernadette? was a lifeless exercise wasting Cate Blanchett. Still, those are small potatoes compared to the great works he's delivered. School of Rock. Boyhood. Dazed & Confused. The Before trilogy alone solidifies him as a master artist. Last year, he made Ethan Hawke's Lorenz Hart pontificating in a bar absolutely transfixing in Blue Moon. Linklater's fascination with the quiet moments of existence and splendid rapport with actors has produced some tremendously impactful motion pictures.
His 2009 film Me and Orson Welles is not one of those titles.
On paper, though, it should be. Whereas other Linklater misfires like Bernadette or Bad News Bears came off as generic mainstream works anyone could've helmed, Holly Gent and Vincent Palmo Jr.'s screenplay (adapted from a Robert Kaplow novel) sounds right up Linklater's alley. His two 2025 movies, Nouvelle Vogue and Blue Moon, showed his love for vintage film directors and the New York Stage scene in the 30s/40s, respectively. Richard Rogers, who appeared in Blue Moon, even gets name-dropped in Orson Welles. Surely, following the Citizen Kane director trying to realize an audacious vision of Julius Caesar on Broadway would be fodder for prime Linklater cinema. Instead, the proceedings remain inert.
Me and Orson Welles transpires through the eyes of 17-year-old Richard Samuels (Zac Efron) in 1937. His impromptu drumroll playing helps him stumble into a small role in a Mercury Theatre production of Caesar that Orson Welles (Christian McKay) is directing and starring in. Welles is a demanding soul who refuses to either commit to a firm opening night or listen to any criticism. Putting on this show is a whirlwind, but for the artistically-inclined Samuels, it's also a dream come true. Plus, he's connecting with production assistant Sonja Jones (Claire Danes), who harbors grand show business dreams connected to David O. Selznick. Orson Welles chronicles Samuels and other characters through the final tormented days of Caesar rehearsals. Nobody dares utter "Macbeth" or "break a leg"; this shows already flooding in bad luck.
One of Gent and Palmo Jr.'s strangest screenplay flourishes is filtering Me and Orson Welles through a Hays Code storytelling lens. Characters can reference "getting into [her] pants" or flip somebody the bird, but that's as bawdy as it gets. Largely, people refer to sex through "quadruple space" (the literary method novels used to use to imply sexual congress occurred), physical intimacy happens off-screen, and the harshest language emerging is one utterance of "bitch." Everyone's personalities and psychological temparments generally could've inhabited an actual 1937 movie.
This attempt to convey a period-piece ambiance instead renders Me and Orson Welles too facile. Countless actual Hays Code films (like Night of the Hunter or Ace in the Hole) creatively communicated realistic nuances and darker complexities while working within Hays Code restrictions. Peak movies in this era proved so riveting that the larger artistic confinements never enter one's mind. Orson Welles, meanwhile, emulates the creative constraints, but none of the implicit depth of those titles. Everyone remains a shallow caricature (one leading lady is constantly obsessed with her appearance, for example) while the world seems too squeaky-clean. It's like Gent and Palmo Jr. are emulating a concept of what Hays Code-era cinema was rather than the real deal.
That quality alone brings down Me and Orson Welles, considering Richard Linklater's films often thrive on authenticity. Works like the Before trilogy or Boyhood excel because they let viewers peek through a window into everyday life as it naturally unfolds. The characters always feel tangibly real as they smoke, swear, and exhibit all the jagged edges of everyday life. Blue Moon, meanwhile, infused potently real yearning and angst into the chatterbox historical figure Lorenz Hart. Heck, the more mainstream, narrative-focused School of Rock gets one of its most tender scenes out of Jack Black's character organically reassuring an insecure student about her body image issues. His concern and reassurances here feel movingly real.
In contrast, few in Me and Orson Welles come off as living, breathing people. Linklater's dialogue-driven, hangout vibes that were so entertaining in Dazed & Confused aren't so successful when applied to these figures who rarely drink, never swear, and can balance on fire hydrants with inhuman ease. The tangible, messy humanity Linklater's works often highlight is MIA here.
Strangely, the character of Orson Welles is both the film's saving grace and, unfortunately, epitomizes the production's surface-level creativity. On the latter front, Welles, in terms of screenwriting, rarely goes anywhere super unexpected. He's the brash, know-it-all creative type who inevitably backstabs people. What you see is what you get. Meanwhile, the cutesy "ain't he a stinker?" approach to him flirting and wooing every lady in sight is eye-roll-worthy. On the other hand, Christian McKay's casting in the role is phenomenal on several fronts. For one thing, it's intriguing that they made Welles older than he actually was when he directed this Ceasar production. Opting for McKay (who was in his mid-30s in the late 2000s) to play Welles when he was 22 reflects a welcome willingness to do what's right for the movie rather than slavish historical fidelity.
Meanwhile, McKay's quite extraordinary in the part. He's got the silky smooth Orson Welles voice down pat, while imbuing the character's cockiest maneuvers with such assuredness that you can buy why people would succumb to his charms. Better yet, though, McKay is wise to incorporate little bits of physicality or memorable line deliveries that make sure he isn't just parroting the past. He finds a balance between yesteryear and making something new. Plus, Welles lunging at the back-talking Samuels is the one moment where Me and Orson Welles displays verve. Now that the characters are fighting, all bets are off as to what this movie can do.
This altercation and Welles declaring to Samuels both "you talentless little shit!" and "you're a God-gifted performer" within two years are, unfortunately, anomalies in their jagged, imperfect humanity in the otherwise too tidy Me and Orson Welles. Still, McKay makes both those moments sing, and he's otherwise sublime in the entire feature. He could stand toe-to-toe with the best performances in Linklater's filmography.
Generally, Me and Orson Welles looks handsome (if too stagnant in its unchanging lighting), particularly with the period-era costumes. All those 1930s garbs are sharply realized via costume designer Nic Ede. Also on the positive side, Claire Danes and Zoe Kazan are charming in their respective roles even though the script doesn't give them anything to do. Kazan especially does all she can to make her persistently insecure character feel like a person. Competency is found throughout Me and Orson Welles, but little in the way of specificity. While Orson Welles changed cinema forever and refused to settle for standard visual techniques, this title about his 30s stage exploits is frustratingly banal.
That's despite Me and Orson Welles being, on paper, a much busier production than certain Linklater movies. It even has a ticking clock motivating its plot! Yet the deluge of subplots and old-timey actors colliding prove infinitely less interesting than kids jumping on wooden boards in an abandoned house in Boyhood or Julie Delpy doing that one yearning-soaked gesture in Before Sunrise. Linklater's artistic gifts lie in making the small captivating. He dares to suggest that the most intimate or low-key parts of life are also worthy of cinematic representation. A cookie-cutter enterprise like this that ends with a classroom equivalent of "and then everybody clapped" works against those impulses.
Honestly, though, if Me and Orson Welles was just a test run for his excellent Blue Moon (which benefited from both a more confined scope and Ethan Hawke's Lorenz Hart being an infinitely better anchor for a movie than Zac Efron's Samuels), then it was all worth it. Plus, this 2009 feature's shortcomings make it even easier to appreciate how Linklater's best movies soar.

No comments:
Post a Comment