Where Do You Wanna Go?

▼

Sunday, November 8, 2026

Queerness forever! Or: La Bola Negra, Cloud Atlas, Moonlight, and queer stories told over multiple generations

Massive Spoilers for La Bola Negra, Cloud Atlas, and Moonlight ahead

It is 1937. In Spain, trumpeter Sebastián (Guitarricadelafuente) scrambles atop toppled statues. The village he was performing in has been bombed. Even the most prestigious effigies aren't immune to fascist Italian forces bombing civilians. There is fear in Sebastián's heart. But also a fierce determination to survive. As he traverses all this rubble in one of La Bola Negra's earliest scenes, you can feel his rapid, stress-induced heartbeat and sweat beads dripping down his forehead. 

It is 1936. Composer Robert Frobisher (Ben Whishaw), one of several Cloud Atlas lead characters, is penning a letter to his lover, Rufus Sixsmith, just before he takes his own life. "I believe there is another world waiting for us, Sixsmith. A better world, and I'll be waiting for you there," Frobisher recalls. "I believe we do not stay dead long. Find me beneath the Corsican stars, where we first kissed." 

It is 2016. Moonlight protagonist Chiron Harris (going by the name "Black") is an adult (portrayed by Trevante Rhodes) traveling to Miami, Florida, to see Kevin (André Holland), his teenage crush with whom he shared a sexual encounter on a beach years ago. After talking at the diner where Kevin works, they head back to Kevin's domicile. Here, after keeping himself withdrawn the entire night, Chiron finally opens up. "You the only man that's ever touched me," Chiron remarks before choosing his next words carefully. "You're the only one," he continues, "I haven't really touched anyone since."

The decades vary. The circumstances change from bombs dropping to savoring a final sunrise to a tender conversation in a Miami apartment. None of these characters could ever conceivably meet. Yet the motion pictures La Bola Negra, Moonlight, and Cloud Atlas all inhabit a similar mold. They're all unabashedly queer works divided into segments transpiring over multiple eras. Their timelines each vary heavily in scope (Moonlight covers basically 20-25 years, La Bola Negra covers 90 years, while Cloud Atlas spans centuries), yet each feature utilizes massive passages of time to explore varying corners of queer existence. 

These three movies didn't create this storytelling template or even utilize expansive, multi-timeline narratives for queer experiences in art. Yet they do create an intriguing spiritual trilogy in queer cinema history. La Bola Negra, Moonlight, and Cloud Atlas are forever intertwined in how they thoughtfully use time to reflect the endless variety and eternal persistence of queer lives.


Queerness forever! Literally!

Typically, in mainstream cinema (especially in the American film scene Moonlight and Cloud Atlas* originated from), queer lives are finite. A trans character in And Justice for All... only exists fleetingly to motivate Al Pacino's cis-protagonist, including with her off-screen death. Meanwhile, the ubiquitous knowledge of the "bury your gays" trope reflects how commonly American films/TV shows kill off queer characters and deprive them of a happy ending. This isn't some arcane storytelling technique either. As recently as late 2010s genre movies Atomic Blonde and It: Chapter Two, gay characters were slaughtered to juice tension in stories. The default norm for queer cinematic lives is to reinforce their limited (and tragic) lifespans.  

On the most basic level, La Bola Negra, Moonlight, and Cloud Atlas use their stories to subvert the limiting, finite nature of traditional queer narratives. People still die in these stories, including Robert Frobisher killing himself or Sebastián's secret lover, Rafael Rodríguez Rapún (Miguel Bernardeau), perishing via firing squad. However, these deaths inhabit films committed to demonstrating expansive queer existences and aesthetics. Frobisher's lover, Rufus Sixsmith (James D'Arcy), for instance, is the rare Cloud Atlas character to appear in multiple stories since his older self appears in the film's 1973-set storyline. Sebastián living long after Rapún's horrific death, meanwhile, is a core component of La Bola Negra. Tragic deaths are not the sole end destination for queer characters in these works. Spanning so many decades offers immense storytelling tableaus to emphasize this.

Moonlight, meanwhile, doesn't necessarily feature any queer deaths. Telling its story across multiple time periods instead illustrates Chiron's evolution over two decades. Writer/directory Barry Jenkins (adapting a story from Tarell Alvin McCraney) charts him from a bullied child finding unexpected solace in Juan (Mahershala Ali) to a bullied teenager to an adult emulating classical "tough" masculinity. As Stephen G. Hall describes in his February 2017 essay "Man-Child Under the Moonlight: Black Masculinity in the Promised Land"... 
Chiron is a man-child in the moonlight. As a man-child in the moonlight, he negotiates the complex terrain related to maintaining an outward facade of masculinity clothed in toughness and the inner turbulence of his nascent homosexuality. This negotiation creates a resolvable tension in the film which is worked out under the magical luminescence of the moonlight...The viewer is treated to a complex portrait of masculinity and homosexuality in black communities that is seldom explored in the mainstream media. Moving beyond the clichés of a monolithic, rabidly anti-gay black community and the erroneous association of black masculinity with muscularity and thuggism, the film gazes deep into the lived experiences of its characters.
Filming Chiron's life over so many disparate eras allows that "complex portrait" to take on so many intricacies. Queer lives relegated to the background in other movies are here, and in Cloud Atlas and La Bola Negra, chronicled for decades and allowed to become more than just thinly-sketched caricatures. Moonlight's use of this storytelling approach while focusing on one character (rather than the sprawling ensemble casts of the other two features) is especially moving since it provides a cinematic reflection of how ever-evolving queer identities are. Chiron's drastic changes across each Moonlight section illustrate how queer people aren't static. Our personalities, relationships with our gender and sexualities, larger worldviews, they're all constantly in flux. Moonlight showcasing multiple time periods in one movie vividly and poignantly crystallizes that.

A larger tapestry of queer history

All three of these motion pictures are also fascinated with history and how the past reverberates into the present. La Bola Negra makes this concept not subtext, but explicit text in its story. One of the films three storylines focuses on playwright/historian Alberto (Carlos González) (who exists in the year 2017) scouring for information on both his recently deceased grandfather and a manuscript this distant relative left behind. When he isn't getting Grindr notifications or struggling to communicate with his mother, this man is searching for evidence related to queer history. Evidence that gay lives existed in decades past has been suppressed, but it hasn't been erased. Alberto can keep these stories going into the present and beyond. With that manuscript, a bridge between gay past and present has been constructed.

Another bridge forms when Alberto learns not only that his grandfather is Sebastián, but also meets Sebastián's lover. This elderly man recounts how he met Sebastián, the long walks they shared, and how this distant grandfather did keep track of Alberto's professional accomplishments. Sebastián is physically gone, yet he's still here through the way he impacted his partner and the anecdotes he's inspired. It's the same way Frobisher's memory clearly still runs through Sixsmith's brain in the 1973 Cloud Atlas segment. Someone who died decades earlier still endures. 

In the modern world, commentators across the political spectrum try to dismiss queer existences as "that trans fad" or only vital when they're not "in your face about it." All across the LGBTQIA+ community, various forms of erasure seek to wipe out any traces of queer lives, past, present, and future. However, to quote an unforgettable manifesto from Andor, "Tyranny requires constant effort. It breaks, it leaks. Authority is brittle. Oppression is the mask of fear.” All of this dehumanization is meant to mask how worlds devoid of queer and trans lives have never existed. Even in eras past, when they had to hide themselves in alleyways or artistic subtext, queer people were here. 

Modern queer folks like myself are following in the footsteps of 20th-century legends like Marsha P. Johnson and Angela Davis, who themselves added pieces to a puzzle started by other LGBTQIA+ souls from decades prior. The multi-generational approach of these three movies reflects this reality. Even Moonlight, which spans 20-ish years rather than the centuries of Cloud Atlas, captures how the past bleeds into the present. In the third segment of this Barry Jenkins directorial effort, this phenomenon manifests more tragically, as Chiron emulates Juan (right down to his wardrobe and automobile) and surface-level external representations of "manly masculinity" rather than using Juan's lessons and thoughtful pearls of wisdom to become a standalone person. The fears of being bullied and socially ostracized for his queerness (a fixture of his High School life, another tragic manifestation of the past soaking into the present) have led to him becoming withdrawn and embracing a simulacrum of "classical" masculinity. 

Chiron finally seems most comfortable and himself when he finally opens up to Kevin about how he's never been intimate with another man since that fateful beachside encounter years earlier. When he unveils his own inner world, Chiron finds (however temporary) peace. "At some point, you gotta decide for yourself who you gonna be," Juan once  imparted to adolescent Chiron, "Can't let nobody make that decision for you." In this tender moment in Kevin's kitchen, Chiron makes this father figure proud not by being his clone, but by living up to these wise words. Once Chiron starts channeling the past to make a glorious new present, richly human and tender possibilities for a better tomorrow open up.

Being part of a larger queer tapestry doesn't mean rigidly mimicking yesteryear's LGBTQIA+ icons, let alone becoming mirror reflections of straight-presenting people. It means utilizing the idiosyncrasies of these trailblazers as inspiration for pursuing what makes us happy. There isn't a mold for being "properly" queer, nor is there a handbook for how to explore or realize your own identity. Existence is pervasive improvisation. Queerness is no different. These three movies spanning so many points in time make it clear queer characters inhabit vast historical tapestries, but also that their lives are not interchangeable. Sebastián is not the same person as Alberto. The trans girly DJs seen in La Bola Negra are not indistinguishable from Robert Frobisher. Ideally, queer history inspires further exciting variations and evolutions in queer identity. La Bola Negra and Cloud Atlas use their towering narrative scopes to explore this concept, Moonlight's comparatively more confined storytelling scale also potently explores how the past and present influence queer identity. 

Speaking of using massive stories to reflect endless variations in queerness...

Queer stories go anywhere and everywhere

All three movies explore multi-generational queer storytelling, but they're far from the same motion picture regurgitated three times. Specific themes (the fluidity of identity in Cloud Atlas, Spain's history in La Bola Negra, Black masculinity in Moonlight) underpin each story, highlighting their distinct creative impulses. Meanwhile, these titles jostle between different eras to explore wildly different genres and aesthetics. Cloud Atlas is the most obvious example of this, with its towering script jumping between 70s conspiracy thriller, wacky retirement home comedy, Blade Runner-esque sci-fi adventure, and post-apocalyptic survival movie (among other molds). Think queer storytelling looks like one thing? Cloud Atlas's gargantuan creative ambitions refute that perception.

La Bola Negra, meanwhile, has three storylines varying in atmospheres and styles. Alberto exists in a more grounded drama, while Sebastián inhabits a period piece war movie (complete with the doomed romance often anchoring historical epics). Carlos (Milo Quifes), a figure serving as the anchor of the titular play, exists in a slightly more fanciful world prone to grand visual metaphors divorced from grounded reality. Moonlight doesn't hop between sci-fi and wacky yukfests across its three storylines, but Chiron's various ages across the disparate segments ensure each portion has its own atmosphere. Wistful reminiscence (the kind underpinning titles like Cinema Paradiso) often informs the initial story concerning Juan offering pearls of wisdom to young Chiron. Once Chiron's an adult, reunited with Kevin, transfixing yearning fills the screen, echoing In the Mood for Love. 

All this variety scattered throughout these three movies and their disparate pieces reinforces how much variety exists throughout the queer community. Not only does queerness exist in every historical era, it also manifests in every form imaginable. Queer art can look like cannibals on horseback in Cloud Atlas or mournful trumpet playing in a show in La Bola Negra or staring into another man's eyes across a restaurant booth. All three of these features also implicitly communicate to queer viewers, "the LGBTQIA+ community has room for anything, including you." 

Beyond being queer stories told over multiple segments transpiring over long stretches of existence, little else binds La Bola Negra, Cloud Atlas, and Moonlight together. In details big (like the dearth of explosions in Moonlight compared to the other two films) and small (the varying approaches to orchestral music in all three titles), they're wildly different projects. Moonlight's use of multi-generational storytelling (to reflect how masculinity-based societal expectations affect boys/men over time) is different from La Bola Negra's (which captures how queer existence quietly endures during historical erasure). Ironically, that makes them a perfect trio to capture the boundless possibilities of queer art and existence. 

Our history is vast. 

Our art and community members can look like anything. 

Whether it's the 1930s, 2016, or any other year, queerness is also limitlesness. 

Allow these three movies and their expansive narratives to reflect that so vividly. 

"I understand now that boundaries between noise and sound are conventions. All boundaries are conventions, waiting to be transcended. One may transcend any convention if only one can first conceive of doing so. Moments like this, I can feel your heart beating as clearly as I feel my own, and I know that separation is an illusion. My life extends far beyond the limitations of me." - Robert Frobisher, Cloud Atlas

* = Cloud Atlas, because of its independent financing sources, is technically considered a German or United Kingdom movie. However, because Lana and Lilly Wachowski are American-born filmmakers, not to mention it being an English-language film anchored by American performers like Tom Hanks, Halle Berry, Susan Sarandon, and Keith David, it's considered an American movie for this piece. Sorry Germans!

No comments:

Post a Comment